Blog
Blog · 16 November 2026 · 9 min read
Epics, Deities & History

Great Minds Who Used Astrology, and Why Vedic Astrology Goes Deeper

Carl Jung read horoscopes for his hardest patients and wrote to an Indian Jyotishi about it. Kepler, Pauli and the Reagans used astrology too. What each of them was really after, which famous quotes are fake, and why Vedic astrology reads a person in far more layers.

By Sandesh
9 min read
Great Minds Who Used Astrology, and Why Vedic Astrology Goes Deeper

In September 1947, Carl Jung, the most famous psychiatrist alive, sat down to answer a letter from Bangalore. It came from Professor B. V. Raman, editor of The Astrological Magazine, the Jyotishi who later translated the Prasna Marga into English. Jung told him he had studied astrology for more than thirty years. When a patient was hard to diagnose, he said, he got their horoscope to see them from a completely different angle, and the chart often explained things he could not otherwise understand.

Read that again. This is not a fairground palm reader. This is the man behind introvert, extrovert and the collective unconscious, telling an Indian astrologer that the birth chart helped him with his hardest cases.

I am not going to argue whether science approves of Jyotish. That debate misses the point. The better question is what the sharpest people in history actually used astrology for, and what they would have seen with the full Vedic instrument in their hands.

What did Carl Jung actually use horoscopes for?

Jung used horoscopes to understand character, not to forecast events. In 1911 he told Sigmund Freud that his evenings were going into astrology, casting horoscopes to get at the psychological truth inside them. Freud was wary. Jung kept going for the rest of his life.

His idea of how it works was precise. He did not believe the planets push people around. He called the link synchronicity: the sky and the person show the same pattern at the same moment, without one causing the other. Raman, in his notes to the Prasna Marga, reached for exactly this idea of Jung's to explain why omens and events line up. The conversation between Zurich and Bangalore ran both ways.

In 1952 Jung published his long essay on synchronicity, including a statistical experiment on the horoscopes of married couples, in one book with Wolfgang Pauli, winner of the 1945 Nobel Prize in Physics. Pauli's half of that book was about Johannes Kepler. (I have written separately on why Jung cast horoscopes for his patients and modern psychology dropped the habit.)

Which famous scientists were also astrologers?

The founders of astronomy were astrologers, and they saw no contradiction. Three names settle it.

  • Ptolemy, 2nd century Alexandria, wrote the Almagest, the astronomy textbook of Europe and the Arab world for some 1,400 years, and the Tetrabiblos, the textbook of astrology. Same author, same sky.
  • Varahamihira, 6th century India, compiled five systems of Indian astronomy in the Pancha Siddhantika and wrote the Brihat Jataka, which Jyotishis still study line by line. Its second chapter opens with a map of the human being: the Sun is the soul, the Moon the mind, Mars vigour, Mercury speech, Jupiter knowledge and happiness, Venus love and desire, Saturn sorrow. That is a model of the psyche, written about 1,400 years before Jung.
  • Johannes Kepler (1571 to 1630) found the three laws of planetary motion that every physics student still learns. As imperial mathematician in Prague he cast horoscopes, including one for the general Wallenstein in 1608. In 1610 he published a book whose title page warns scholars not to throw out the baby with the bathwater: reject the superstition, keep the real thing. He mocked the almanac fortune-tellers of his day. So do I.

Why did presidents and bankers hire astrologers?

Because power runs on timing. After the attempt on Ronald Reagan's life in March 1981, Nancy Reagan began consulting the San Francisco astrologer Joan Quigley. In 1988 the former White House chief of staff, Donald Regan, revealed in his memoir that nearly every major move on the Reagans' calendar had been cleared with her first. Nancy Reagan confirmed the consultations in her own memoir a year later, while denying that astrology ever shaped policy. Quigley later claimed she picked the hour for the 1987 signing of the nuclear arms treaty with Mikhail Gorbachev.

Look at the question they were asking. Not "what will happen to us?" but "when should we move?" Jyotish has a whole branch for that question: muhurta, the science of choosing the moment. In India it is so ordinary that the NSE and BSE stock exchanges open a special one-hour Muhurat Trading session every Diwali; this year's was on 8 November 2026. You can find your own auspicious windows with the free muhurat finder.

What could Jung and Kepler not see that a Jyotishi computes?

They had the twelve signs, the houses and the transits. They did not have the Vedic layers that turn a chart from a portrait into a working model of a person over time. This is what I compute that their astrology either lacked or did far more crudely:

What a Jyotishi computesIn plain wordsWhat it adds to understanding a person
The sky as it actually is (sidereal zodiac)Signs measured against the fixed stars. Today they sit about 24 degrees behind the Western zodiac.For most people the Vedic Sun sign is one sign earlier than the Western one, and the whole chart shifts with it.
The Moon's birth star (nakshatra)The Moon's path split into 27 stars of 13 degrees 20 minutes each, instead of 12 signs.Varahamihira makes the Moon the mind. The star it sits in describes how that mind works, far more finely than a sign can.
The planetary clock (Vimshottari dasha)A 120-year sequence of planetary chapters, its starting point set by your Moon's birth star.Shows which part of your nature is running your life in which years, and the date that changes.
A chart for each area of life (divisional charts)The birth chart re-divided: the Navamsa (D9) for marriage, relationships, dharma and inner strength; the D10 for career.A planet can look weak in the birth chart and strong underneath, or the reverse.
Strength in numbers (Shadbala, Ashtakavarga)Six kinds of planetary strength scored in units, and every sign given a points total.Separates a planet that wants something from a planet that has the power to deliver it.
The soul planet and the public image (Atmakaraka, Arudha Lagna)The planet at the highest degree in its sign is the soul's significator; the Arudha Lagna is how the world sees you.Jung wrote about the self and the persona. Jyotish computes both from the same chart, as two separate points.

None of this is decoration. Each layer can overturn what the one before it said. Read more on the planetary clock, on planetary strength, and on the Moon and its birth star.

Why does one placement never describe your mind?

Because the same placement means different things in different charts, and only the full computation tells you which. Take the line pop astrology loves: "Moon in Scorpio: intense, jealous, secretive."

Here is the classical starting point. Parashara puts the Moon in its debilitation, its weakest sign, in Scorpio, deepest at 3 degrees. Pop astrology stops at the label. A Jyotishi only starts there. Four people, all with the Moon in Scorpio:

PersonWhat else the chart showsHow I read the mind
AMoon at 3 degrees Scorpio, the exact point of its fall. Born in the dark half of the lunar month. No benefic planet looking at it. Now running the Moon's own dasha.The fall is felt in full. Feelings run deep and heavy and are slow to settle, and these Moon years are when it shows most.
BSame Moon, but Mars, the ruler of Scorpio, sits in an angular house (the 1st, 4th, 7th or 10th) from the rising sign.The fall is cancelled. Pressure turns into drive: the person who rebuilds after every blow.
CMoon in Scorpio a day or two before full Moon, with Jupiter aspecting it.A waxing Moon counts as a benefic, and Jupiter's aspect protects it. Deep feeling, held steady: the friend everyone calls in a crisis.
DMoon at 1 degree Scorpio, which falls in its own sign, Cancer, in the Navamsa.Weak on the surface, strong underneath. The person who looks fragile and turns out to be the hardest to break.

Same label, four different minds. And I have not yet touched the Moon's birth star, its strength score, the house it rules or the transits running over it. This is the work Jung was reaching for with the tools he had. A column that gives every Scorpio Moon the same paragraph is not astrology. It is a greeting card with a zodiac sign on it.

What should a skeptic take from all this?

That the question was never "is astrology science?" The question is whether the instrument is good enough for the job. Jung, Kepler and the Reagans each reached for astrology because they needed a second angle on a person or a moment that their ordinary tools could not give them. They did it with the twelve-sign version.

Jyotish is the full version, and it is demanding. It needs your exact birth time, because a few minutes can move your rising sign, change your Navamsa and shift your dasha dates by weeks. It needs every layer computed and read together. And it needs someone willing to tell you what the chart says, not what you hoped to hear.

That is what Supastro is built to do: it computes these layers from NASA JPL ephemeris data and reads them together, the way a Jyotishi would. Start with your free kundli, then ask the AI Oracle the question you actually care about.

Frequently asked questions

Did Carl Jung believe in astrology?

Yes, as a tool for understanding people. Jung studied astrology for more than thirty years and looked at patients' horoscopes in difficult cases to see their character from another angle. He did not treat it as fortune-telling: he explained the link between sky and person as synchronicity, a meaningful match in time rather than a physical cause.

Which famous scientists practised astrology?

Ptolemy, whose Almagest ruled astronomy for some 1,400 years, also wrote astrology's textbook, the Tetrabiblos. Varahamihira wrote both Indian astronomy and the Brihat Jataka. Johannes Kepler, who found the laws of planetary motion, cast horoscopes professionally, and Galileo cast them for his own daughters.

Did Isaac Newton believe in astrology?

There is no good evidence that he did. The famous line "I have studied these things, you have not" was a rebuke to Edmond Halley about religion, and it was retold as a defence of astrology only from around 1910.

Did J.P. Morgan say "Millionaires don't use astrology, billionaires do"?

No source for that quote has ever been found. His astrologer, Evangeline Adams, did claim in her 1926 memoir that she taught Morgan astrology, but the famous one-liner appears to have been attached to his name later.

Did Ronald Reagan use astrology?

Nancy Reagan consulted the astrologer Joan Quigley from 1981, after the attempt on the President's life, and Quigley's advice shaped the timing of his schedule. Chief of staff Donald Regan made it public in 1988; the Reagans said astrology never shaped policy.

How is Vedic astrology different from Western astrology?

Vedic astrology measures the signs against the fixed stars, so most planets sit one sign earlier than in a Western chart. It adds layers Western astrology does not use: the Moon's 27 birth stars, the Vimshottari dasha clock, divisional charts such as the Navamsa, and numerical strength through Shadbala and Ashtakavarga, all read together.